Back to Home
Back to Civitas Archive

Civitas No. 36 -- April 17, 2003

The Broadside of Local Politics and Civic Design

Our Motto: “You have to hack your way through a lot of lunchmeat in this world."

Quote of the Month: "My father rode a camel. I drive a car. My son flies a jet airplane.
                                  His son will ride a
c
amel”    -- Saudi Saying

“Mad Dog” Lands New Day Job, Lenz Kicks off Run, and other occult auguries of spring — by Jim Kunstler

     Officially he resigned from his day job as chief administrative officer of the big Albany law firm Whiteman, Osterman, White & Hanna, but we heard that city Accounts Commissioner Steve (“Mad Dog”) Towne was actually cashiered on short notice. In any case, he has landed on his feet as chief administrative officer at the Roohan Real Estate agency here in town, owned by city Republican party chairman, Tom Roohan. Roohan and Towne are cousins.
      This ought to raise some serious questions about Towne’s fitness for his particular city office. As accounts commissioner he is in charge of real estate assessments. As a member of the city council Towne frequently has to vote on city development issues. As an employee of a leading realtor, can he maintain his independence and objectivity?
      Just after Towne went on the Roohan payroll, Roohan withdrew his lawsuit against the city for a reduction in the assessment on his Broadway building (where Putnam Market is located). Otherwise, the lawsuit would have left Towne in the awkward position of having to defend the city against the company he works for. Roohan’s building at 433 Broadway was originally assessed at $2.5 million. He was granted a $500,000 reduction by an appeals board in 2002. The lawsuit was seeking an additional $500,000 reduction.      Meanwhile, we hear that commissioner Towne has still not attended classes for assessment certification, as required by law. Now that his commute time has been reduced, he may be able to fit that into his schedule.

Lenz Launches Campaign for Mayor

     How will announced mayoral candidate Mike Lenz explain to the voters how he came to be so consistently on the wrong side of the issues? Take the water issue. Lenz is staunchly in favor of the county water plan instead of the city’s own plan. The county plan would cost about $100 million more than the city’s plan, would deprive the city of control over its own destiny, and could lead to the hyper-suburbanization of northern Saratoga County.
     
Meanwhile, Lenz’s Republican machine has whipped up a frenzy among the Saratoga Lake residents to oppose the city’s water plan, on the entirely fake grounds that boating would be restricted. Of course, these yahoos won’t be voting in the city election.
       Lenz has been on the wrong side of land-use issues. He voted against the purchase of the Ramsdill boat launch property on Lake Lonely under the city’s new Open Space acquisitions program. He pretended to be in favor of the Open Space bond act until the time came to sign his name to a newspaper ad endorsing the measure, when he made himself scarce.
        Lenz has taken a position against the city opting out of the county’s unfair sales tax formula, despite the evidence that for years the county had been sucking money out of the city like a Hoover vacuum.      Why has Lenz taken so many patently indefensible positions against the city’s interest? The answer is simple: he does whatever the county bosses tell him to do.

YMCA to Relocate Out in Left Field

      The Saratoga YMCA is going forward with purchasing 23 acres off West Avenue in a remote corner of the outer city that has very poor pedestrian connections. The idea, apparently, is to build a suburban-style facility with plenty of parking and lots of athletic fields. We question the wisdom of this.      
      This facility will be finished just as the US enters a long period of chronic oil shortages and disruptions that will spell the end of suburban-style way of doing things. We will be living in a world of greatly reduced driving (and parking). The investment in athletic fields is redundant inasmuch as the nearby high school already has a full complement of fields, in addition to the East and West Side Rec fields.
      It will be difficult for kids to walk or ride their bikes to this location. We believe this proposed facility will be obsolete before it even opens.

Church Restoration Moving Ahead

     John G. Waite Associates Architects of New York City and Albany, one of the nation's leading restoration architecture firms, have been hired to do the design work on the Universal Preservation Hall, on Washington Street. The building is a stellar example of High Victorian Gothic architecture, and was built as a Methodist church in 1871.
     In recent years, the Universal Baptist Congregation made its home there, but found the enormous structure too great a challenge to maintain. Now, in a unique partnership between a church congregation and a new nonprofit organization, the building will become the Saratoga Springs Universal Preservation Hall, and will house both the congregation and a performing arts center.
      We believe this project will turn out to be one of Saratoga's most important restoration projects, as it will return a magnificent downtown building to public use while reactivating the currently moribund Washington Street.

Trouble With Henry Street Condo Project

      Rumor central says that developer Scott Trefillo has run into a nasty problem with his proposed six-story condo building on Henry Street between Phila and Spring Streets — a project we support, by the way.
      Apparently a building that size needs to be connected to high pressure natural gas lines, but the only lines in the old “Gut” district are low pressure. The high pressure junction is way over on the other side of Broadway.
      It would be in the city’s interest — getting a high revenue luxury condo building on the tax rolls — to support Trefillo in his negotiations with the Niagara-Mohawk company. Specifically, we urge the mayor to take an active role in jawboning with the utility company. The project was originally scheduled to begin construction this spring.

A Tragedy in Washington County

     The closing of Mary McClellan Hospital in Cambridge comes at a weird time in our national history. Life still seems pretty normal — the parking lots are still full of jousting SUVs — yet we are on the threshold of momentous change that will be brought about by the end of the cheap oil age.      
      The future will require us to live more locally. We will have to live closer to work, grow more food near where we live, and take care of our sick and injured closer to home. In other words, the Cambridge hospital is closing just at the time when we should be moving in the direction of re-localizing. We will discover that it’s not so easy to restart an institution once it is locked and shuttered.

Dust Up over Hub Building
     
      The Adirondack Trust was recently prevented from bulldozing the Hub building at Church St and Railroad Place when the Preservation Foundation stepped in to stop it using the legal tools at its disposal. The site of a once-popular Skidmore college gin-mill has stood by itself in a strip of vacant lots for decades. Last year, it was sold to the bank, which announced its intention to put up another building on the site.
      Trouble was, the bank had not yet proposed or received approvals for any new building — and there was no sign of when they might get going on such a project. In the meantime, the bank felt it could lower the property tax by a few thousand dollars by razing the building.
      The Preservation Foundation felt that such a move would leave Church Street looking like a bombed-out wasteland. Anyway, the move to halt the bulldozers left bank president Charles Wait furious at Preservation Foundation director Carrie Woernor, with tremors roiling the usually-placid philanthropic sector of the community.
      There is general agreement that the old building was not worth saving. We think Woerner did the right thing, though. The street would have been a horrendous eyesore for God-knows how long. Maybe now the bank will be inspired to hire an architect and get on with the job.

Tick Tock Tick Tock Tick Tock Tick

      We tend to view local events and issues through the lens of the world oil situation. It now seems clear that the global peak oil production phenomenon occurred in 2000-2001. This means that annual production will never again be higher than it was then, no matter what happens on the demand side — and by the way, demand has only kept growing. What’s more, from now on annual worldwide oil production will only decrease.
      2003 is already off to a bad start, with Iraq out of commission, and Venezuela and Nigeria hobbled by civil unrest. The ramifications of this are enormous. Among other things, it means that industrial economies can no longer depend on 2 to 5 percent rates of annual growth. It means that suburbia is obsolete. It means the end of WalMart. The oil peak phenomenon will change everything.

     
Stay tuned.